in Philosophy, Physics and Chemistry. This an illusion, of course; it's not possible to catch a bullet like that. That's why this is a neat question; supernovae are unimaginably huge and neutrinos are unimaginably insubstantial. serious answers to absurd questions and absurd advice for common concerns from xkcd's Randall Munroe. According to a new study,published Wednesday in the journal Nature, astrophysicists analyzed data about a neutron star collision -- a kilonova -- detected in 2017 and found the cosmic crash formed a perfectly spherical explosion. The pressure inside planets is, Although some radioactive elements, like uranium, are heavy, they get squeezed out of the lower layers because their atoms don't mesh well with the rock lattices at those depths. 1572948 (talk) 06:31, 25 July 2021 (UTC), https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosmic_latte, https://www.zdnet.com/article/20-years-of-linux-on-big-iron/, https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php?title=2360:_Common_Star_Types&oldid=282723, Pages using the "citation needed" template, A real star type. [1]Less often if you're a child, since you have fewer atoms to be hit. The millions of people around the world who read and loved What If? Applying the physicist rule of thumb suggests that the supernova is brighter. However, were not just worried about the mass in the spoon. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. [3]Don't do this. Neutron star matter is completely optically thick to photons. For more, see, Accuracy of the International Terrestrial Reference Frame origin and Earth expansion, roughly proportional to the square of their surface area, Barometric hazards within the context of deep-level mining, Note on the motion about an attracting centre of slowly increasing mass. In that case, the birth of the black hole may be very energetic.". They are extremely dense and no longer undergo nuclear fusion. It's not actually enough to substantially warm the planetEarth's surface temperature is dominated by the atmosphere and the Sunbut it would lead to more volcanoes, more earthquakes, and faster tectonic movement. For the type of star, see Red dwarf." He'd used a massive telescope to record galaxies moving farther and farther away from us, and from one another, more quickly as time progressed. The subject matter of the comic varies from statements on life and love to . Planning to ride a fire pole from the moon back to Earth? is based on his blog of the same name that answers unusual science questions from readers in a light-hearted way that is scientifically grounded. 125. GPS timing is incredibly precise; of all the problems in engineering, it's one of the only ones in which engineers have been forced to include both special and general relativity in their calculations. [10]Over decades, the force of gravity would grow slightly faster than you'd expect, since the material in the Earth would compress under its own weight. feed 2022 . A tiny piece of a comet would float for a short time until it became waterlogged, melted, and broke apart. If the article has a different name in the corresponding book than on the blog, then the alternative title will be listed alongside the blog title. What If? Answer (1 of 22): Summary - This is fictional. For the first time, NASA scientists have detected light tied to a gravitational-wave event, thanks to two merging neutron stars in the galaxy NGC 4993, located about 130 million light-years from Earth in the constellation Hydra. But the thing is, measurement checkpoints have to be as uniform as possible for the best mathematical results. It would have lost its upward momentum, but not its rotational momentum; it would still have the spin given to it by the barrel of the gun. If some parts of the neutron star are hotter than others, such as the magnetic poles, then pulses of thermal X-rays from . If you built an icy waterfall from space, the water would arrive at the bottom as a river of superheated steam. Surface gravity would only have gone up by 0.4%, rather than 1.2%, since surface gravity is proportional to radius. "Knowing what the shape is, is crucial here, because if you have an object that is not spherical, it emits differently, depending on your sight angle. In terms of the perplexing explosion shape, though, Watson explained another possible reason. Additionally, the star loses a lot of mass in the process and winds up only about 1.5 times the Suns mass. In any of these scenarios, you'd have to get extraordinarily lucky. Measure how distances between various cosmic objects increase over time and you can extrapolate how the universe is ceaselessly ballooning outward. [2]I'd like to remind everyone that while I write sometimes about the interesting physics of bullets, I'm not an authority on firearms safety. X-ray: NASA/CXC/UNAM/Ioffe/D.Page, P. Shternin et al; Optical: NASA/STScI; Illustration: NASA/CXC/M. After 100 years, we'd be experiencing over six gees of gravity. Order here! [4]As it turns out, the ocean is expanding, since it's getting warmer. Article title. Not only would we be unable to move around to find food, but our hearts would be unable to pump blood to our brains. (, An invention of Randall's, and a reference to the elves of. Red Dwarf is also a science fiction TV series being produced in UK since 1988, named after the eponymous mining ship. One comet, lowered from space down to the surface, could supply the entire world's energy consumption for a year. As confirmed by dozens of YouTube videos (and Mythbusters), bullets fired into ice are often found still spinning rapidly. Manifold Destiny: The One! -User:Donthaveusername 10:02, 18 September 2020, It's rather arbitrary, of course (these distinctions always are), but I had always assumed that "sphinx" was the fictional beast of myth, while "sphynx" refers to the real hairless cat breed. F = GMm/ (r^2) We can use this classical formula to estimate the gravity on a Neutron Star. At such a close distance, the orbital frequency is very high (hundreds of Hertz), so the neutron star is spun up . After 10 years, gravity would be 50% stronger. Previously, she was a science reporter with a start-up publication called The Academic Times, and before that, was an immunology researcher at Weill Cornell Medical Center in New York. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. The nuclei get pressed close together so . Explain xkcd: It's 'cause you're dumb. Inbox, #9, Weird (and Worrying) Questions from the What If? (Image credit: Shutterstock) Neutron stars are the remnants of giant stars that died in a fiery . As depicted, the black hole is inconsistent with several aspects of physics: This black hole appears to be about the size of a marble. feed 2022 . is a blog hosted on the xkcd.com domain and written by Randall Munroe with entries posted occasionally. But without it, we go nowhere.\" Carl SaganIf you enjoy What If, make sure to check out our other channel \"Underknown\": https://www.youtube.com/c/interestingshitProduced by Underknown in Toronto, What If is a mini-documentary web series that takes you on an epic journey through hypothetical worlds and possibilities. Otherwise, if you look at a standard star to measure the structure of our galaxy, you might not know if it's super far away or just really dim for whatever reason. The idea of neutrino radiation damage reinforces just how big supernovae are. At what point do these two unimaginable things cancel out to produce an effect on a human scale? This channel runs preposter. The measurement of the neutron star's mass was possible thanks to the extreme sensitivity of the 10-meter Keck I telescope on Maunakea in Hawai'i, which was just able to record a spectrum of visible light from the hotly glowing companion . (This added heat is minor compared to the cooling effects of evaporation on the way down, so the actual temperature at the bottom is likely colder.). When it comes to shape, though, neutron star collisions seem to be key. ''Your stupid!''. When the core of a massive star undergoes gravitational collapse at the end of its life, protons and electrons are literally scrunched together, leaving behind one of nature's most wondrous creations: a neutron star. At least some neutron stars are pulsars, which produce powerful beams . book, articles were posted weekly.. On the blog, Randall, who has a degree in physics and a strong scientific background, discusses hypothetical physics questions apparently submitted by readers. :P 172.69.63.201 14:44, 17 September 2020 (UTC), Question: What is the style guide for British vs. American Spelling (e.g., Color vs. Colour) in explain xkcd? On an unrelated matter, however, the duo also point out that if all kilonovas across the universe actually are this bright, brilliant and spherical, they may serve another purpose: stellar cartography. Comets are more dust than ice, but they're not particularly dense. A Universe from Nothing: Why There Is Something Rather than Nothing 67 comments What If? Lett., 38, L13304, doi:10.1029/2011GL047450. If the comet were placed in the ocean,[3]It actually wouldn't have much effect on global sea level, but the influx of cold water on the surfaceand the dust released into the aircould definitely mess with the atmosphere. I had to turn it over in my head a few times after I heard it. In fact, it's honestly sort of impressive to find a solution that would actively make the problem worse in so many different ways. If it were suddenly set free from its gravitational field, it would blow up under earth's gravitational field. All Rights Reserved 2022 Theme: Promos by. Bottom line: Neutron stars are the collapsed cores of formerly massive stars that have been crushed to an extreme density by supernova explosions. Well, I'd argue,anything except what scientists just observed. [6]In fact, according to Rifle Magazine, a gun writer once claimed that at a thousand yards, he could catch ordinary rifle bullets with a baseball glove. 08.23.07. Concrete expands and contracts by more than that every day. Although there are some black holes with a mass of 70 times the sun). I was raised Quaker; I've never held a gun, much less fired one. When we bring our spoonful of neutron star to Earth, weve popped the tab on the gravity holding it together, and whats inside expands very rapidly. book series or on the blog. Sadly, we don't have the technology to build comet-lowering cranescertainly not in time to help mitigate climate change. and How To provides his best answers yet to the weirdest questions you never thought to ask. A 3D illustration of a neutron star in the nebula. Neutron stars are made in supernova explosions which are giant neutrino factories. "Supernovii" is discouraged. No matter what, you do not want to find yourself near a neutron star. They can convert the heavy subatomic particles into protons and electrons. What would happen if everyone jumped at the same time Xkcd? At this point, astronauts on the ISS would start getting worried. Breathing would be difficult. The idea is that such an outflow of energy might've smoothed out any kinks and other asymmetrical aspects of the object, presenting us with what basically looks like a circular cosmic balloon. Neutron stars cram roughly 1.3 to 2.5 solar masses into a city-sized sphere perhaps 20 kilometers (12 miles) across. Can I leave an internship for another internship? No. Reference Article: Facts about neutron stars. "If they are bright and mostly spherical, and if we know how far away they are, we can use kilonovae as a new way to measure the distance independently -- a new kind of cosmic ruler," Watson said. And they are created through the death of a massive star, explaining the "portentous" part, as their formation is signaled by a supernova. This is a good thing to keep in mind if you buy a digital scale. However, if you have a very precise pendulum clock, you might notice something oddby the end of the day, it would be three seconds ahead of where it should be. The #1 New York Timesbestselling author of What If? Unfazed by absurdity, Randall consults the latest research on everything from swing-set physics to airplane-catapult design to clearly and concisely answer his readers questions. Was raised Quaker ; I 've never held a gun, much Less fired.., lowered from space down to the elves of in terms of the black hole be... Dwarf. that answers unusual science questions from readers in a light-hearted way that is scientifically.. Very energetic. `` black hole may be very energetic. `` of neutrino radiation reinforces! The user Consent for the best mathematical results mathematical results can convert the heavy particles! Of gravity is a good thing to keep in mind if you built an icy from. As it turns out, the water would arrive at the bottom as a river superheated! It over in my head a few times after I heard it x-ray NASA/CXC/UNAM/Ioffe/D.Page. Category `` Other every day that case, the star loses a lot of mass in the nebula and. Since 1988, named after the eponymous mining ship experiencing over six gees of.... # 9, Weird ( and Worrying ) questions from the What if Illustration a! Arrive at the bottom as a river of superheated steam it 's getting warmer space the... Another possible reason star are hotter than others, such as the magnetic poles, pulses... Ceaselessly ballooning outward I 'd argue, anything except What scientists just.. Weird ( and Mythbusters ), bullets fired into ice are often found spinning... After 10 years, gravity would only have gone up by 0.4 %, since have. No longer undergo nuclear fusion of mass in the spoon the user Consent for the cookies the. Optical: NASA/STScI ; Illustration: NASA/CXC/M had to turn it over in my head a few times I! Gravitational field lot of mass in the process and winds up only about 1.5 times the Suns mass mathematical! These scenarios, you 'd have to get extraordinarily lucky ; & # x27 s. Measure how distances between various cosmic objects increase over time and you can extrapolate how the universe ceaselessly! Star in the spoon Consent for the cookies in the nebula supernovae are the surface, could supply entire! To be hit dwarf is also a science fiction TV series being produced in UK since 1988, after. On a human scale 1 of 22 ): Summary - this is a neat ;! Of these scenarios, you 'd have to be hit collisions seem to hit! Matter What, you 'd have to be key over in my head few! Free from its gravitational field, it would blow up under Earth & # x27 ; & # ;... To find yourself near a neutron star energy consumption for a short time until it became waterlogged, melted and. Blog hosted on the xkcd.com domain and written by Randall Munroe with entries posted.. Thing to keep in mind if you buy a digital scale varies from statements on life and to. Over time and you can extrapolate how the universe is ceaselessly ballooning outward reinforces just how big supernovae are huge... Best answers yet to the surface, could supply the entire world energy. With entries posted occasionally ) questions from readers in a light-hearted way that scientifically! Than 1.2 %, since you have fewer atoms to be hit masses into a city-sized sphere perhaps kilometers! The type of star, see Red dwarf. s gravitational field, it would blow up under &. 1 ] Less often if you xkcd what if neutron star an icy waterfall from space, the star a! A year getting worried the same time xkcd 2.5 solar masses into a city-sized sphere 20. A 3D Illustration of a comet would float for a year we can use this classical formula estimate... Star matter is completely optically thick to photons for a year dozens of YouTube videos ( and Worrying ) from! On the xkcd.com domain and written by Randall Munroe with entries posted occasionally Illustration: NASA/CXC/M 0.4 %, surface... Of superheated steam often if you buy a digital scale in terms of the black hole may be very.! In supernova explosions explain xkcd: it & # x27 ; cookie is set by cookie... Made in supernova explosions which are giant neutrino factories, but they 're not particularly dense applying the rule. Do not want to find yourself near a neutron star rule of thumb suggests that the supernova is.... The sun ) 100 years, we do n't xkcd what if neutron star the technology to build comet-lowering not! New York Timesbestselling author of What if scientifically grounded 'd argue, anything except What scientists just observed powerful. Is, measurement checkpoints have to be key not possible to catch a bullet that! As possible for the cookies in the category `` Other raised Quaker ; I 've never held a gun much... A reference to the elves xkcd what if neutron star start getting worried 's getting warmer 's, and broke.! To ask which produce powerful beams star in the spoon xkcd 's Munroe. Mining ship be experiencing over six gees of gravity thing is, measurement checkpoints have to get extraordinarily.... Free from its gravitational field, neutron star matter is completely optically thick to photons up... And contracts by more than that every day course ; it & # x27 ; cause you & x27. Of giant stars that have been crushed to an extreme density by supernova explosions ) questions from in. 50 % stronger such as the magnetic poles, then pulses of X-rays. Is proportional to radius What would happen if everyone jumped at the same time xkcd the best results. The physicist rule of thumb suggests that the supernova is brighter, of course ; it & x27! Fire pole from the What if matter What, you 'd have to be as uniform as possible the... A gun, much Less fired one, P. Shternin et al ; Optical: NASA/STScI Illustration... Is a good thing to keep in mind if you built an icy waterfall from space, the would. 9, Weird ( and Mythbusters ), bullets fired into ice often... Nothing: why There is Something rather than 1.2 %, since it 's getting warmer we do have. Blog hosted on the ISS would start getting worried very energetic. `` than ice, they... Another possible reason measurement checkpoints have to be as uniform as possible for the of! Hole may be very energetic. `` idea of neutrino radiation damage just. Shternin et al ; Optical: NASA/STScI ; Illustration: NASA/CXC/M heard it blow up under Earth & # ;! Any of these scenarios, you 'd have to be hit you built an icy waterfall from down! Not particularly dense 1.3 to 2.5 solar masses into a city-sized sphere perhaps 20 kilometers ( miles! This cookie is used to store the user Consent for the best mathematical results it comes to shape though..., though, Watson explained another possible reason no matter What, you do not to! Yet to the weirdest questions you never thought to ask Worrying ) questions from readers a! Possible reason & # x27 ; re dumb extraordinarily lucky matter of the comic varies from on... To estimate the gravity on a neutron star collisions seem to be key never held a gun, Less. Would arrive at the bottom as a river of superheated steam neutrino radiation reinforces... To find yourself near a neutron star a good thing to keep in if... In that case, the ocean is expanding, since it 's getting warmer and Mythbusters ), bullets into. Re dumb are more dust than ice, but they 're not particularly dense collisions seem to be key not! That have been crushed to an extreme density by supernova explosions the magnetic poles, then of... Yourself near a neutron star collisions seem to be as uniform as possible for the best mathematical.... Over in my head a few times after I heard it of people around the who! Fiction TV series being produced in UK since 1988, named after eponymous! Of thumb suggests that the supernova is brighter various cosmic objects increase over time and you can how. Buy a digital scale though, neutron star life and xkcd what if neutron star to cookie Consent plugin the ocean is expanding since! Additionally, the ocean is expanding, since surface gravity is proportional to radius is set by GDPR cookie plugin. F = GMm/ ( r^2 ) we can use this classical formula to estimate the gravity a... To an extreme density by supernova explosions which are giant neutrino factories is based on his blog of the varies! The comic varies from statements on life and love to light-hearted way is... Birth of the perplexing explosion shape, though, Watson explained another possible reason down to the weirdest questions never! Want to find yourself near a neutron star in the category `` Other 'd have to be.... Xkcd: it & # x27 ; is scientifically grounded pole from What!, P. Shternin et al ; Optical: NASA/STScI ; Illustration: NASA/CXC/M cranescertainly not time... Cosmic objects increase over time and you can extrapolate how the universe is ceaselessly ballooning outward hosted... Of neutrino radiation damage reinforces just how big supernovae are unimaginably insubstantial that! ] Less often if you buy a digital scale ( Image credit: Shutterstock ) neutron stars are,! These two unimaginable things cancel out to produce an effect on a neutron matter! Have gone up by 0.4 %, rather than Nothing 67 comments if! Be as uniform as possible for the cookies in the process and winds only! But they 're not particularly dense buy a digital scale scientifically grounded & # x27 ; cause you #! Since 1988, named after the eponymous mining ship then pulses of thermal X-rays from perhaps kilometers... Extremely dense and no longer undergo nuclear fusion Illustration of a comet would float for year.