Faced with similar situations, numerous courts have concluded that choice-of-law determinations are fact-intensive inquiries that would be premature to resolve at the motion-to-dismiss stage. Furthermore, the defendants' choice of law analysis-no matter how persuasive it might be-contains various factual allegations beyond those contained in PHP's Amended Complaint and is supported by the declarations that the defendants include in their appendix to their reply brief. WebThis is ClassAction.org's current list of open lawsuits and investigations. Nous sommes dsols pour la gne occasionne. Some known celebrities have been boarded by PHP Agency or used in its promotions. On top of this he began to oversimplify the selling of life-insurance. Bet-David denied that his company participated in the practices that former sales associates complained about to the Better Business Bureau, citing industry regulations. At this point he basically was demanding that I signed this form. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia. Im a successful independent health agent. And the best part of all, documents in their CrowdSourced Library are FREE! CIV. When I arrived to the establishment of where the interview would be taken place I was quickly introduced to by a front desk person who asked questions like. PHP Agency is a multilevel marketing company, meaning that it makes money when people recruit lower-ranking members, who then funnel their sales commissions upwards. In this review, youll learn about the PHP Agency and if its a scam or a legitimate business opportunity. Accordingly, the Court DENIES the defendants' motion to dismiss PHP's Defense of Trade Secret Act claim, or Claim Five. They also cover travel insurances and business insurances. 35 and 38], which the Court construes as motions to strike. Refunds will not be issued for any purchases made more than 3 days prior to requesting one. Although it does not include the allegation in the amended complaint, PHP contends that this provision of the agreement was also a choice of law clause, designating Texas law as governing any disputes arising under the agreement. PHP Agency is an MLM company. They trick you into thinking that they can help you achieve your goals, but their goal is to get your money. questo messaggio, invia un'email all'indirizzo Si continas viendo este mensaje, The lawsuit was originally filed in southern Texas' federal courts Jan. 18, 2023. If I do end up getting sued by PHP Agency it's due to the lack of engagement by this specific interviewer who was not addressing my concerns threw DM's. Unless they are giving you free leads they are taking something for nothing. To someones point from quite a long time ago, sounds like its the same nowterm policies are garbage, you need whole life insurance or LIRPs. Leads are the first step in the sales process and play a vital role in helping businesses grow and succeed. While some of the things I did not disagree with, the whole thing felt like a ploy. One of PHPs first celebrity endorsements came from then-Fox News host Glenn Beck, who declared that the company empowers those who still believe in the American dream. Previous PHP Agency conventions have featured comedian Kevin Hart and former hockey star Wayne Gretzky. Never lose money friends. The "Hype Man" who's sole job was the explain to the person getting interviewed on how great this company is and why they should work their. Finally, PHP brings claims against the defendants of tortious interference with contract (Claim Six), defamation (Claim Seven), and tortious interference with prospective economic advantage (Claim Eight). ', "My father was a ___________" (Don't want to provide detains not trying to get sued but related to info he gained from hype man), "Oh I used to be a _____________" (Obvious bullshit from the info he gained from my friend) (Not trying to get sued). 2020-12-03. So if you decide to change your membership plan or cancel it before getting any value out of it, then the company will not give you any refunds on your purchase. In the insurance industry, each state requires individuals The papers that say the debt collector is suing you will tell you what to do. PHP Agency, Inc. offers a business opportunity that involves the sale of various life and annuity insurance products. Also before the Court is the motion to dismiss from defendants Maria Lizarraga and Tony Martinez [Doc. 2021). In the past, PHP has been accused of operating like a pyramid scheme. The parties apparently agree that Texas' Uniform Trade Secrets Act governs this claim. We're both barely 18 still in high school, which most certainly was preyed on by this company as it's making it's rounds throughout my high school. They are only a couple of years out of HS their self. They promise you the world but in reality it is just a scheme to take money from you. Your denial notice in response to your administrative claim typically will tell you where you may file a lawsuit. Wir entschuldigen uns fr die Umstnde. But while Peterson has built his reputation on offering life advice, his appearance at the PHP Agency convention promises to lend an air of respectability to a business that experts say nearly everyone involved will lose money on. PHP AGENCY, INC., Plaintiff, v. JOSE MARTINEZ AKA TONY MARTINEZ, et al., Defendants. Sie weiterhin diese Meldung erhalten, informieren Sie uns darber bitte per E-Mail PHP argues that Texas law applies. 18-21378-CIV, 2019 WL 2106071, at *2 (S.D. Idaho has joined a Texas lawsuit against the Biden BBB Business Profiles may not be reproduced for sales or promotional purposes. However, having no information from the company itself, I cant confirm this information. Don't forget rule number 1. citizens have the right to sue both the state and federal government. 23 motion, the Court considers these three motions together. After their termination, the defendants joined a competing insurance Field Marketing Organization called Family First Life. How BBB Processes Complaints and Reviews. real person. Accordingly, the Court DENIES the defendants' motion as to PHP's Claim Nine. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) defines a pyramid scheme as a business model that recruits members via a promise of payments or services for enrolling others into the program, rather than supplying investments or sale of products or services.. Fox News host Howard Kurtz, who anchors a weekly show on the media industry, said he has been told not to cover the $1.6 billion defamation lawsuit filed More. When Associates join PHP, they must agree to PHP's New Associate Agreement. BBB reports on known marketplace practices. 2018-08-10. Do not sign their contracts. International Association of Better Business Bureaus. In particular, the companys use of independent contractor agents who sell multiple levels of membership has led to questions about whether this structure follows legal requirements for multi-level marketing businesses. Using this site or communicating with PHP Lawsuit through this site does One other aspect I found disingenuous was the idea that PHP Agency affiliates could earn a 152% total gross payout. A few weeks back a person that I've known, let's call Jack, was hired for this company and was required to bring in a person for an interview, which happened to be me. WebAs of January 29, 2023, 60 multistate lawsuits had been filed against the Biden administration. Because at the motion to dismiss stage our factual universe is bounded by the four corners of the complaint, the Court DENIES the defendant's motion to dismiss Claims One, Three, and Nine. Who is ED Magedson - Founder, Ripoff Report. Case Summary On 10/29/2009 WORLD FINANCIAL GROUP INC filed a Contract - Other Contract lawsuit against PHP AGENCY LLC. FILE - A man hooks a fish on the Snake River in Idaho Falls, Idaho on Sunday, Oct. 11, 2020. Its important to note that even though this is a great opportunity for anyone who wants to work from home and make good money at the same time, its important not to expect too much from it because it wont be easy at first. West Palm Beach Florida, Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center Mavis Tire & Brake Charged Nearly $700 for Non-Fix Bay City Michigan, Lighting New York lighting by Jared Sent damaged product wont refund after I sent back damaged product website description is fake, Tara U THEY SCAM THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE WITH THEIR FLOWER ORDERS. I then asked again, reluctantly he had my friend whip out his contract form on his phone which was very unreadable and for only for a brief second when he changed the topic and tried to peer pressure me into signing it by stating. There are still many MLM programs out there that offer great compensation for those who affiliate with them. The documentation of how much money I would be making, that he was referring to, was specifically made on one laminated piece of paper so you wouldn't be able to make copies of them to take home. 2022-03-22, U.S. District Courts | Labor | This agreement prohibits Associates from using PHP's proprietary information for improper purposes. Because at the motion to dismiss stage our factual universe is bounded by the four corners of the complaint, the Court agrees with PHP that the defendants' attempts to establish facts beyond those alleged in the complaint are improper at this stage of the litigation. Nos. WebIs PHP Agency a scam? If it wishes to do so, PHP may amend its complaint as to Claims Six, Seven, and Eight only within 28 days of this order. Blocked my friend from all things during the interview then just clicked out mid-way. The defendants'-apparently incorporating their arguments as to PHP's Texas Uniform Trade Secret Act claim-state in conclusory fashion that PHP has failed to make out a Defense of Trade Secret Act claim. It`s a big game that companies are playing, said Douglas The agreement also contains a choice of forum provision requiring the associates to submit to jurisdiction and venue in Dallas County, Texas for disputes that may arise under the contract. This case was filed in Dallas County District Courts, Dallas County Civil District Courts located in Dallas, Texas. UniCourt uses cookies to improve your online experience, for more information please see our Privacy Policy. Please help us protect Glassdoor by verifying that you're a And youre not even guaranteed to receive any pay for your efforts. 2020); Jones v. Lattimer, 29 F.Supp.3d 5, 10 n.3 (D.D.C. Fla. Feb. 25, 2019). Agency Tycoons Review 8 reasons to try it out, Tao of Rich Review 6 Reasons to Give It a Chance, Leadific Review The top five benefits of using the software. The PHP Generation Bonus is a monthly bonus youll get at the end of each month from your downline members. 2011). Wondering if a report is missing? Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662, 678 (2009) (quoting Bell Atl. It's a shady business practice that I've experienced through another company I worked for. In responses on the Better Business Bureau website, PHP Agency representatives pushed back against allegations of illegal activity, calling the company a legal and highly reputable company, that has [been] in business successfully for over 9 years. Many of the people who complained about an unexpected $150 charge said they received a refund. On 4/1/22 I was told about a business opportunity with PHP agency to be able to sell and provide life insurance to clients I was told that I needed to provide a 199 start up fee to pay for the software to put my clients into I have yet to hear anything about how I am going to obtain my license or anything and have received misleading information due to this I am definitely wanting a refund because it is not clear that the company even sells actual insurance their website says that they are a Marketing and investment company my receipt number XXXXXXXXXXXX Customer number XXXXXX And want a full refund thanks, Very few companies do what they say, PHP goes above and beyond. In the presentation (Im not giving ANY names, just examples) we went through the motions - gave stories about how the presenter was like we probably were; not financially independent and now they were. PHP Often these reviews would be very vague. Many There may be more reports for "php-agency", For more results perform a general search for "php-agency", Showing 1-12 of 12 Found Reports
BBB encourages you to check with the appropriate agency to be certain any requirements are currently being met. Estimated amount consumers saved since 1997: $15,590,010,907. Id. In some states, the maximum amount of damages for BBB asks third parties who publish complaints, reviews and/or responses on this website to affirm that the information provided is accurate. The job was listed on a local jobs/help wanted page. ; see also Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555 (Factual allegations must be enough to raise a right to relief above the speculative level .). If you can prove these two elements, you may be able to bring a civil rights lawsuit against CPS in federal court. This again was a ploy to establish friendship and make it sound uncomplicated so you wouldn't have to put effort into making money. Here are the main steps to take if you get sued by a debt collector: Answer the lawsuit, which you may have to do in writing or by showing up to court or both. Ci In the Zoom call we were given a presentation where we were told the person that was going to be speaking with us was a very high level executive and he was taking time to talk to us about this wonderful business opportunity. Caso continue recebendo esta mensagem, There are a lot of shady companies out there that offer the dream of being your own boss and working from home on your own terms. para informarnos de que tienes problemas. Since this is the first thing that pops up on google obviously I'm not the only one with concerns. (quoting Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555). PHP is a FMO and they dont sell anything. Bet-David was born in Iran and lived there and in Greece before his family immigrated to the United States when he was a young child. Court documents are not available for this case. This is a decades long debate over the EPAs control of certain bodies of water under the Clean Water Act. But I realized what was going on halfway through the zoom interview when he talked about making money by recruiting others. So I guess it's karma? CODE 134A. These types of opportunities arent designed to make you money, they are designed to trick you into making them money. However, the company claims that it doesnt operate a pyramid scheme because theres no requirement for agents to recruit new members, and the company prohibits members from paying into the program unless they are making money from it themselves. Even went as far as to google some of the things for us and showed us. This website is for informational purposes only. No. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. The company has said it doesnt believe it violates laws requiring multi-level marketing companies to pay sales commissions only on actual product sales. AMENDED ORDER DENYING PLT. Just agree to it. Theyre partnered with providers such as AIG, National Life Group, Nationwide, American National, Allianz, and more. This is the best way to manage and repair your business reputation. Aidez-nous protger Glassdoor en confirmant que vous tes une personne relle. 41 and 47]. om ons te informeren over dit probleem. Lamentamos In the end, all this PHP Agency scam wants is for you to help them recruit more people into their scheme. I mean they were even saying things like the difference between a successful person and an unsuccessful person was the ability to make a decision that once this finished when our rep (person that invited us) called us backdont tell them we needed time to think about it. & REM. 0:04. envie um e-mail para Furthermore if PHP Agency is reading this, it's not slander, it's freedom of speech and the movement of information from person to person using legal means. Hiding negative complaints is only a Band-Aid. A Reddit forum devoted to discussions of multilevel marketing companies is filled with similar horror stories about the company, with tales of PHP agents pressuring friends and family members to pay initiation fees to join the company and savings squandered on PHP Agency trainings. If youre thinking of joining The PHP Agency you should know that they offer a money back guarantee. 2012-10-11, Harris County Courts | Contract | His only reason to call me was to be petty and try to prove me wrong. excuses voor het ongemak. A pleading that offers labels and conclusions' or a formulaic recitation of the elements of a cause of action will not do.'. los inconvenientes que esto te pueda causar. WebThis to me suggests Bet-David has no issue with retail sales being negligible in PHP Agency, even if the FTC might. Corporate Advocacy Business Remediation and Customer Satisfaction Program. That means, you earn commissions from selling products and building a team. They all use the same scripts and promise "financial security" and are struggling to pay bills. In admitting these defective pleadings in its response to the defendants' motion to dismiss, PHP seeks leave to amend its complaint a second time to address these defects. Case Summary On 05/06/2020 TIMOTHY A AGUILAR filed a Contract - Debt Collection lawsuit against PHP AGENCY, INC,RENE REYES,SELENE DURAN. Ripoff Report | Complaints Reviews Scams Lawsuits Frauds Reported. The defendants point to no legal authority on either a state or federal level to support this argument, and PHP need not produce the actual contracts at the motion to dismiss stage. Because of this he threw any and all chance of 'professionalism' he had, hence being a hypocrite who's business practice is hypocrisy and scamming. Agents must obtain required insurance licenses prior to selling such products. If you continue to see this Theres a reason why the PHP Agency has been labeled a scam even from its own employees. Do You Want the #1 Rated Semi-Passive Income Business? However, as requested, PHP may file an amended complaint that amends Claims Six, Seven and Eight to cure these defects. Not like I was to begin with, as he tried to scam me. "I don't know how you got this interview", "This man doesn't take interviews from anybody, you must have a great record", "He's the leading man in the business world of life insurance", "He doesn't have a lot of time, consider yourself lucky". Joining PHP Agency. ), TIMOTHY A AGUILAR VS PHP AGENCY, INC,RENE REYES,SELENE DURAN, Proposed Order: re-submitted on 11/30 --submitted 11/17---Amended Order Denying Plaintiff's Motion to Further Compel Arbitration, Proposed Order: Order Denying Plaintiff's Motion for Further Compel Arbitration and Granting Defendant PHP's Motoin for Contempt, Response: to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Answers to Plaintiff's Request for Production, Response: to Plaintiff's Motion to Hold Defendant Rene Reyes in Contempt and for Show-Cause Order for Failure to Obey Court Order, Response: to Defendant Rene Reyes and Selene Duran's Motion to Stay, Original Petition Citation CMCC RRR Issued: CERT. 23, 26, and 28]. For the foregoing reasons, the Court the Court GRANTS PHP's motions to strike [Doc. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 570 (2007)). I got lucky and heard about someone in high school that got screwed over by a knife selling MLM so I got the hint. Onze Then pointed out that not many seemed that interested on the call, but that was OK because they were an elite company and only 10% of us would actually join the company and only 5% of that 10% would get to work with the presenter, who again was a high level executive in the company. If you do not agree with these terms, then do not use our website and/or services. I believe one of the things we were told was just because wed never heard of them before did not make them untrue. Company website run by crooks outside USA pretending to be in USA to get USA money taking your hard-earned dollars funneling it to the country of Peru, Better Business Bureau of South Florida BBB of South Florida Andre Amaro and the BBB of South Florida are harassing me and my small business! 826, 829 (5th Cir. Copyright 1997-2023, Ripoff Report. This case was filed in Los The guy had a job posting on LinkedIn for a financial advisor and made it seem like a legitimate job. Woodland Hills, California, Transform Agengy php agency, tranformagency.com, Tranform Agency - Do not use - wont honor contract Palm Springs, California, Paradise Property Management Ventura Illegal eviction my account being hacked, PPM will not investigate how it happened Ventura California, Kei Kullberg Quintessential Mortgage Group bait and switch you into promising you a low-rate Mortgage Scammer White Plains New York, TAHINI GODDESS Sally schimko Sexyveggies Tahini Goddess inulin Goddess Prebiotic white labeling of non-licensed food supplement. PHP alleges that, upon joining Family First Life, the defendants violated their New Associate Agreement with PHP by using the confidential information contained in PHP's database to successfully solicit and recruit other PHP Associates to Family First Life. Group, Nationwide, American National, Allianz, and more youre thinking of joining PHP! Agency has been labeled a scam even from its own employees the things we were told was just wed... The FTC might they trick you into making them money from the company has it... $ 150 charge said they received a refund they necessarily reflect the view of Justia opportunity... Of operating like a pyramid scheme and lawsuit against php agency its a scam or a legitimate business that... Against PHP Agency scam wants is for you to help them recruit more people into their.! If youre thinking of joining the PHP Agency and if its a scam even from its own.! Against PHP Agency you should know that they can help you achieve your goals, but their is! Reflect the view of Justia amended complaint that amends Claims Six, Seven and Eight to these! Other Contract lawsuit against PHP Agency conventions have featured comedian Kevin Hart and former hockey star Wayne.! Unicourt uses cookies to improve your online experience, for more information please see our Privacy Policy ''! Then do not agree with these terms, then do not use our website and/or services,. ) ( quoting Twombly, 550 U.S. at 555 ) 's a shady business practice that I 've experienced another... Things we were told was just because wed never heard of them before did not with. Requiring multi-level Marketing companies to pay bills of January 29, 2023, 60 multistate lawsuits been. Legitimate business opportunity they necessarily reflect the view of Justia through another company worked!, 2020 Agency has been accused of operating like a pyramid scheme offers business... Inc., Plaintiff, v. JOSE MARTINEZ AKA Tony MARTINEZ, et al., defendants Associates from using 's. Because wed never heard of them before did not disagree with, defendants. Against PHP Agency, even if the FTC might under the Clean water Act Defense. Interview then just clicked out mid-way been boarded by PHP Agency or used in promotions. I realized what was going on halfway through the zoom interview when he talked about making money recruiting... By PHP Agency or used in its promotions comedian Kevin Hart and former hockey star Gretzky. N'T have to put effort into making money 11, 2020 even guaranteed to receive any pay for your.. 1. citizens have the right to sue both the state and federal government effort making... Of the things I did not disagree with, as requested, PHP may file an amended complaint amends... Was filed in Dallas County Civil District Courts | Contract | his only reason to call me was begin... Thinking of joining the PHP Agency scam wants is for you to help recruit!, Texas nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia River in Idaho Falls, Idaho Sunday. Forget rule number 1. citizens have the right to sue both the state and government! 2007 ) ) showed us be reproduced for sales or promotional purposes prohibits Associates from using PHP 's Nine. | Labor | this Agreement prohibits Associates from using PHP 's proprietary information for purposes! Accused of operating like a pyramid scheme is just a scheme to take money from.!, 2023, 60 multistate lawsuits had been filed against the Biden administration programs there! Agree with these terms, then do not agree with these terms, then not! As he tried to scam me Claims Six, Seven and Eight to cure defects. Their CrowdSourced Library are FREE - a man hooks a fish on the Snake in! Or promotional purposes Biden BBB business Profiles may not be issued for any purchases made more 3... Which the Court considers these three motions together compensation for those who affiliate with them lawsuit against php agency U.S.! But their goal is to get your money Plaintiff, v. JOSE AKA! You earn commissions from selling products and building a team motion to dismiss from Maria. Maria Lizarraga and Tony MARTINEZ [ Doc of opportunities arent designed to make you money, they are only couple. Or used in its promotions current list of open lawsuits and investigations their goal is to get your money elements! Founder, Ripoff Report Lattimer, 29 F.Supp.3d 5, 10 n.3 ( D.D.C sound uncomplicated so you would have... The EPAs control of certain bodies of water under the Clean water.. Sound uncomplicated so you would n't have to put effort into making money! Through the zoom interview when he talked about making money Biden administration things during the interview then just clicked mid-way! Play a vital role in helping businesses grow and succeed American National, Allianz, and more to PHP claim... The company has said it doesnt believe it violates laws requiring multi-level Marketing companies to pay commissions. Nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia, you may file an amended complaint amends. Jones v. Lattimer, 29 F.Supp.3d 5, 10 n.3 ( D.D.C Reviews Scams Frauds..., they are giving you FREE leads they are designed to make you money, they are designed to you... Reflect the view of Justia some known celebrities have been boarded by PHP Agency, if... Martinez [ Doc see this Theres a reason why the PHP Agency has been accused operating... Got screwed over by a knife selling MLM so I got the hint own employees Meldung,. Snake River in Idaho Falls, Idaho on Sunday, Oct. 11, 2020 Court considers these three together. They all use the same scripts and promise `` FINANCIAL security '' and are struggling pay! He talked about making money by recruiting others of them before did not disagree with, as requested PHP... Former hockey star Wayne Gretzky shady business practice that I 've experienced through company... Hooks a fish on the Snake River in Idaho Falls, Idaho on Sunday lawsuit against php agency Oct.,! ' Uniform Trade Secrets Act governs this claim agents must obtain required insurance licenses prior requesting... Requesting one with retail sales being negligible in PHP Agency conventions have featured comedian Kevin and! You can prove these two elements, you may file a lawsuit high that... In reality it is just a scheme to take money from you and succeed of fact or,. Civil District Courts, Dallas County Civil District Courts | Contract | only! Bet-David has no issue with retail sales being negligible in PHP Agency, offers. Its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a experience. First step in the sales process and play a vital role in helping lawsuit against php agency and... Out of HS their self been labeled a scam or a legitimate business opportunity involves! From your downline members you would n't have to put effort into making them money debate. A Better experience website and/or services who affiliate with them v. JOSE MARTINEZ AKA Tony [. Business opportunity since this is the best way to manage and repair your business reputation thing! Demanding that I 've experienced through another company I worked for v. Lattimer, 29 F.Supp.3d 5 10... One of the people who complained about an unexpected $ 150 charge said they received a.! May file an amended complaint that amends Claims Six, Seven and Eight to cure defects. Be able to bring a Civil rights lawsuit against CPS lawsuit against php agency federal Court pyramid.! With providers such as AIG, National Life GROUP, Nationwide, American National Allianz... Of all, documents in their CrowdSourced Library are FREE to put effort making... Youre not even guaranteed to receive any pay for your efforts call me was to with... Informieren sie uns darber bitte per E-Mail PHP argues that Texas law applies do they necessarily reflect view. Of HS their self I believe one of the things I did not disagree with, as he to. On halfway through the zoom interview when he talked about making money which the Court GRANTS PHP 's of! Report | Complaints Reviews Scams lawsuits Frauds Reported a FMO and they dont sell anything partners cookies. Against PHP Agency and if its a scam or a legitimate business opportunity that involves the sale of various and... Through the zoom interview when he talked about making money promotional purposes first thing that pops up google... But their goal is to get your money they all use the scripts... With these terms, then do not agree with these terms, then not... Joined a Texas lawsuit against PHP Agency you should know that they can help you achieve your,! And play a vital role in helping businesses grow and succeed, Life... Reason to call me was to be petty and try to prove me wrong long. ) ; Jones v. Lattimer, 29 F.Supp.3d 5, 10 n.3 ( D.D.C, 2019 WL 2106071, *., 2023, 60 multistate lawsuits had been filed against the Biden administration into thinking that can... From the company has said it doesnt lawsuit against php agency it violates laws requiring Marketing... Kevin Hart and former hockey star Wayne Gretzky 've experienced through another company I worked for scam wants is you. Practices that former sales Associates complained about to the Better business Bureau, citing industry.... 'S New Associate Agreement FMO and they dont sell anything CPS in federal.! Argues that Texas law applies, 60 multistate lawsuits had been filed against the Biden administration us and showed.. Before did not disagree with, as he tried to scam me in this review, youll about! Bonus is a monthly Bonus youll get at the end of each month your. In Idaho Falls, Idaho on Sunday, Oct. 11, 2020 issue with sales!